Tuesday, October 9, 2012

Our Bad. The IMF Dumps The Chicago Story and You Can Too!

Via Krugman and (much more in depth, Antonio Fatas), we get the biggest economic news of the week: turns out when governments spend money, it's not immediately offset by something else, and economies tend to grow. Those of you who may have missed the last 10 20 years might have trouble understanding what all  the commotion is about here, since this used to be the consensus on this topic, and quite frankly it seems logical to anyone who hasn't been forced to sit through advanced macroeconomic seminars or a tea party rally. Which of these two stories seems to make the most sense?
  1. The government contracts to build a road, and spends money to do so. It pays workers, aggregates companies for the asphalt, etc. So wages to construction workers and profits to companies that make road materials go up, and thereby total income in the US goes up by at least as much as the wages and profits in total. Hey, if the workers ever go out for a drink, or some dinner, or use the money to buy a car, it might even go up a bit more, as other folks' incomes rise too (the waitress, the auto salesman, etc.)
  2. The government contracts to build a road, and spends money to do so. It pays everyone like before, and the road gets built. But somewhere, someplace else in the US, another company (or person) thinks, "Wait! The government borrowed that money, and sooner or later it's gonna ask me for more money. Therefore, instead of building that factory (or buying a new washing machine, or going out to dinner) I'm going to be super smart and postpone all of that purchasing, save the money in a rainy day escrow fund to protect against that inevitable government tax increase."  All that postponing offsets the initial road building income, and total production/income in the US stays the same.
I know, #2 sounds a bit far fetched, but maybe you ARE already an economist and you still buy into these "magically offsetting" hyperrational permanent income ideas. Now, let's assume that interest rates are roughly zero, so that by saving I mean basically stuffing all of your money into a mattress. Still believe that folks don't want to invest or buy washing machines because they'd rather save in their mattress for the inevitable doomsday tax increase someday?  Keep in mind that the government borrowed at 0%, so even if you want to "save" for a rainy day and offset the initial purchase you'd have to have NO investments that yield any positive return (or zero convenience yield for any purchases), because in that world you'd still build the factory and use its profits to pay off the future tax increase. Still buy story #2? Congratulations, welcome to your career in macroeconomics at the University of Chicago.  Outside in the real world where actual people live, we're going with story #1.

Oh yeah. You know which other crazy radicals believe story #1? The IMF. Here's the statistical box...see all of those -1's in the left column? 

Let me interpret. They're the error in the multiplier used to estimate the impact of government spending on growth. Multiplier? Huh? Remember story #1? If the government spending led to an increase in income of exactly the same amount, we say the spending had a multiplier of 1 (or that no one "offset" any of it). If story #2 was correct, we'd see a multiplier much less than 1 (say 0 if you want to make Eugene Fama happy!). But what the IMF is saying here is that they messed up. They used a .5 number as a multiplier and it really was about 1.5. Oh, and sorry about the austerity and all that suffering and unemployment the past two years. Our bad. We'll buy you a cognac and some foie gras to apologize. Oh, but you don't have anything to wear to our club? And you want a job? Tsk Tsk. Why don't you just be glad we admitted we were wrong.

The punchline? Multipliers are bigger than 1, unless interest rates are already high or we're at full employment. And if you tell me that .25% is high or that we're always at full employment (or there now) let me wait while I go find a wall to punch and a bottle of whiskey to drink.

Friday, October 5, 2012

Meat Loaf, the Rear View, and Payroll Employment

You know that warning about "Objects in the Rear View Mirror Are Closer Than They Appear"? I love that. It's also a song by Meat Loaf, which is a subject for a whole other day, or maybe lifetime.  What might not be apparent is that safety, Meatloaf Meat Loaf, and the Payroll Employment Report have something in common. What? They aren't the same looking backwards. There's a lot of good reasons for this, and it's something that the BLS is very up front about, since the initial estimate of jobs comes from relatively poor data, whereas the later revised data is much more accurate. Let's go to the BLS:
Given this short collection cycle for the first preliminary estimates, many establishments are not able to provide their payroll information in time to be included in these estimates. Therefore, CES sample responses for the reference month continue to be collected for two more months and are incorporated into the second preliminary and final sample-based estimates published in subsequent months. Additional sample receipts are the primary source of the monthly CES employment revisions.
As we replace statistically projected data with real data, things get better. What is not as well known is that these revisions are not necessarily uniform through the business cycle. Let's add up the total job revisions in each year and graph them:
 Big negative revisions in recession year (really lagging the onset of recession year), positive revisions elsewhere. All this means is that the statistical projection used by the BLS is conservative; it doesn't want to go nuts every month and scream about jobs and have to explain this whole "statistics" thing over and over again. In normal times, this works great. But in recessions and recoveries, this conservatism means that recessions are initially understated as are subsequent recoveries. While you weren't watching, 877,000 jobs disappeared in 2008, and a million more appeared in 2009 to the present.

News media? We're waiting...

Thursday, October 4, 2012

Ignorant or Stupid, Part 1

William King has an article in the Houston Chronicle titled "The Real Story Behind Rising Unemployment" which he pitches as a post-partisan, reasoned discussion of the impact of government regulation on employment in America. It is both wrong in its conclusions and misleading at best in the use of "facts". His primary conclusion is that since the unemployment rate has a rising trend since 1950, and he asserts that there has been massive regulation of the workplace constantly since the same time, these two trends cause each other. I'll quote:

So if unemployment has been getting worse for the last 60 years, including periods when both parties were in power, it would seem to raise the question whether there is a cause for it other than the ideological hogwash to which we are constantly subjected by both parties.
The answer is no mystery. Anyone who has been an employer for the last several decades, as I have been, can easily provide the answer. Our tax and regulatory policies have increasingly discouraged hiring more employees.
 I'm going to leave all of the easy criticisms to the side...well, I'll just list them at the bottom so we can get on with the really wrong stuff. 

Problem #1: The unemployment rate is a rate. If you're going to write about something, you should know what it is...if you don't know, then you're merely ignorant. If you do know what it is, but still get things wrong about it, well then, you're stupid. The unemployment rate is the number of unemployed people divided by the labor force. What's the labor force? Well, I'm glad you asked. It's a construct of the Bureau of Labor Statistics that measures the number of persons available for work. This changes every month along with the number of unemployed persons, and for that reason, virtually all serious economists and most assuredly the Federal Reserve ignore the unemployment rate and look at the employment to population ratio. This directly measures the number of jobs as a percentage of the total population, which is exactly the measure you'd like for a long run analysis of trend employment. (Actually, for this ratio you'd like the payroll employment number, to avoid problems with self-employment and agriculture effects, but both measures track each other very well.)

Problem #2: The employment to population ratio is skyrocketing up over the period Mr. King claims has been the height of regulatory burden for US employers. Let's take a look:

From 1960-2000, the percentage of employed population went from 55% to 65%, with most drops associated with...recessions (as you note, unemployment rises in a recession when demand drops, which is an assertion that actually is true). This is the giant period of regulation that Mr. King will be telling us about in subsequent weeks; it's associated with massive job creation even above and beyond the absorption of all those newly born workers. In fact, the most anemic rebound from a recessionary drop is associated with the relatively (financially at least) deregulated 2000's.

This is what happens when you start with conclusions and try to find facts. Play me out, Talking Heads:
Facts are simple and facts are straight 
Facts are lazy and facts are late 
Facts all come with points of view 
Facts don't do what I want them to 

P.S. I didn't forget about all the other problems.
  • Correlation/causation, blahblahblahblah
  • No evidence provided about the trend of business regulation and its covariation with the unemployment rate...
  • International comparisons to prove the point...wait, they mostly go the opposite way. Why is unemployment so low in China, for instance, but the US ranks 4th in the World Bank Doing Business Index and China ranks 91st?
  • And finally, for all you "mathematicians" out there, I'll note that regressing the unemployment rate on ANY measure of business regulatory burden is a horribly wrong thing to do, since the labor force is endogenously determined by the regulatory climate.

Tuesday, August 9, 2011

Budgetary shenanigans


Noticed (via Greg Mankiw) this post, which purports to show the massive increase in Federal Government spending over the years of the Obama Administration. It's wrong...or rather, it doesn't graph the right thing. What matters (somewhat obviously) is non-defense discretionary spending...not the BEA number which includes all entitlements. Now if the author's point is that Obama should have immediately cut SS, Medicare, etc. magically during the 2 years that the Democrats controlled the Congress, than that might be the right picture. If you care about the policies of the Obama Administration's impact on the economy, you can see it right here.

Monday, March 29, 2010

Two Cow Garage

Two Cow Garage - "American Static" from TCSG on Vimeo.



Seriously. Just go see them if they happen to be near you...west coast in April, this means you.

Inflation and hyperinflation


Ok, not a secret that I like to characterize my politics as anti-stupid. And it's rare in economics for folks to say something that's outright idiotic, since so many economists (and even more of their more Milquetoast brethren, the finance specialists) like to qualify every statement they make. As in, not "GDP growth will rebound to 2004 levels" but "given the extant data and current policy environment, there is the likelihood that growth in several measures of economic activity may achieve levels previously achieved for some sectors of economies on certain unspecified continents". It's the kind of Laodicean lukewarmness that makes you want to puke.

This is all to preface the fact that I DO really like it when people take a stand. Just not when they're so blatantly wrong and obviously fear-mongering. So what am I going out on a limb about? Hyperinflation. As in, the US will not have hyperinflation in my lifetime. See that period right after that sentence? It means what you think it does. Now if it was just these people equating US monetary policy with the Under Siege II style train wreck that is Zimbabwean monetary policy, I wouldn't be bothered (ok, maybe I would, but not seriously). Or even these people, with their fancy graphs and what not.

But no, reasonable people are weighing in on this, and by this, I mean Michael Kinsley of the Atlantic Monthly. Paul Krugman called him out on this, thankfully, and Greg Mankiw plays referee.

I'm not going to weigh too far into this, because Ryan Avent has done a fantastic job already. The key point is that he notes that hyperinflation is as much about political institutions as about economic activity and I'd add any comparison of countries that doesn't hold this key variable constant is ludicrous. And of course, comparing America to Zimbabwe on this dimension is pretty much like comparing A to Z. It's almost like everyone forgot it used to be called political economy.

The biggest open issue (after the Kinsley "apology") is the worry about how the US will pay back its large (and growing) national debt. Krugman has an answer here, and his reasoning is fairly along the lines of why I remain concerned, but unpanicked. The way I see it, there are really two ways out of the debt: grow faster or spend less (note that spend less also includes tax more). Both of these are in nominal terms as well, so if you could simultaneously fool all investors and index all wage contracts, then inflation would get you out as well. In reality, all of these things would be done simultaneously, and that means you don't need drastic revisions in any one of them. The small note I'll add to the discussion is that people seem to be missing is correlation. These factors are all self-reinforcing. That is, if we are growing faster, the deficit will be smaller, and inflation will be bigger, all of which combine to lower the deficit faster than looking at each factor in isolation. Similarly, standing at a point in time where growth and deficits are large, and deflation is a risk, the problem is likely to look insurmountable. Note that because of the positive feedback, large values of each factor aren't necessary to see large improvement over short periods of time. Remember the late 1990s?


So shockingly, since I'm quintessentially a half-empty sort of guy, this is NOT keeping me up at night. The Law and Order SVU marathon on the other hand, is.

Redux, my new favorite word

Ok, so it's been awhile, but here we are to plunge back into the fray once more. Those of you bored with the Stone-Cold Lock section can rest easy; all of the bets have been settled, and that series is luckily on hiatus until fall. The new look blog will definitely skew more towards finance and macro, but once I get bored with that, there'll definitely be some new more random postings on cheese, delicious white trash cookery, and music. Ideas welcome, as are comments. Please comments. Everyone remember: I AM a glutton for reassurance.